Revolution in Chinese Education?

Last week the New York Times Magazine ran a nice in-depth article on the changes afoot in China's education system--the shift away from the ages-old pedagogical tradition with its emphasis on rote memorization. It's very much worth a read.

One of the questions I'm asked again and again concerns where and how I want my children educated. Do I send them to a local Chinese school? To international schools? Will I want to send them back to the States for study at some point, and if so, at what stage? At least with secondary and post-secondary education, I see the situation as still very fluid (and, thankfully, still a ways off in the case of Guenevere, who's about to turn 3, and Johnny, just 13 months old). Who knows? 14 years from now, Tsinghua and Beida may be better schools than Harvard or Stanford or Cal.

I'm optimistic about the future of Chinese education--at least S&T education--for a number of reasons. First, there's the Internet: with Google putting libraries on line, and with dissertations and other research from leading university labs in the U.S. just a download away now, there's bound to be a leveling effect--and diffusion across this osmotic gradient will be (hell, already is) really fucking fast. Then there's the obvious factor--the sheer will and increasing economic clout of those hordes of hyper-competitive parents who are involving themselves very seriously in the educational lives of their precious only children. And then there's the top-down push: the recognition of the need for fundamental changes in pedagogy on the part of the technocrats up top, obsessed as they are with turning China into a genuinely innovative society. It's now enshrined in the 11th Five Year Plan, and I think it's much more than lip service: it's budgets for R&D, it's more funding for experimental schools, it's a deliberate effort to learn how higher education in the U.S. became what it is.

The problem in science education in China was best summed up at a conference I attended a few years back by a CASS economist whose name I've now forgotten. He said that in the developed West, the scientific method is based on hypothesize, observe, and revise your hypothesis; in China, conversely, it's about observation, hypothesis based on empirical observation, then more observation to test that hypothesis. The problem with the Chinese version he illustrated beautifully: No one ever observed a nuclear fission reaction in nature.

Comments

[the Admiral]

I tend to believe that the problem (if there is one) tends to be a lack of extracurricular activities. Also, the whole lack of the "lemonade stand" mentality.

In parts of the US and Europe, young teenagers have an oppurtunity to learn entrapeneurship (spelling).

Also, I believe, that as a rule the teaching/learning of personal responsibility as it relates to an individual and society prepares the youth to not only learn, but *use* what they learn....

Great blog by the way. Big fan of yours and look forward to hearing you next time you decide to go back on stage.

Cheers

[Micah]

You only half-answered the question you started out with, "how I want my children educated". Any thoughts on the early years?

[Kaiser Kuo]

@ Micah - You're right, I only half answered it. Right now I'm leaning toward sending them to the foreign-student program at a reputable Chinese school like Fangcaodi Elementary in Beijing, where there's bilingual education and quite westernized teaching, I'm told. My daughter will finish out the year we've already paid for at the preschool she now attends--I'm not thrilled with it, and neither is she--and then start at one of Beijing's better Montessori schools until Kindergarten. Little Johnny's doing Gymboree right now, but when he's 2 or 2-and-a-half we'll probably send him to a Montessori as well.

[Micah]

Thanks, that's exactly the kind of perspective I was hoping to get. I'm getting an early start relative to my pack of friends down here in Shanghai and I'm getting nervous about trailbreaking here. I'm leaning towards similar paths: either schools attached to universities, or some of the newer private schools (international or not) with interesting ideas and deep-pocketed investors, like 西外外国语学校. Luckily my wife Jodi is in the preschool business, so she'll be able to keep an eye over the little one when that time comes.

[Custom term papers]

A great article indeed and a very detailed, realistic and superb analysis of the current and past scenarios. I would like to thank the author of this article for contributing such a lovely and mind-opening article.

[Term Papers]

It is good to see that information, really like to share this, this database really helps, Thanks for the information.

[Tana]

Thank you, this really provides very useful information. After my search I finally can find this information. Once again thank you very much

[discount coach]

You must be imaginative, 　　strong hearted. You must try things that may not work. And you must not let anyone define your limits because of where you come from.

[bakugans]

Wow this is a great resource.. I’m enjoying it.. good article

[David]

Thank you so much for all the information. These will surely be a great help.

[china electronics]

Thank you so much for all the information. These will surely be a great help.Chinese school like Fangcaodi Elementary in Beijing, where there's bilingual education and quite westernized teaching, I'm told. My daughter will finish out the year we've already paid for at the preschool she now attends--I'm not thrilled with it,

[generic cialis]

Education is a very important issue, more and more we are been seeing that many kids leave schools for many reasons, something should be done to prevent more kids leaving schools.

[grand canyon tours]

Well, Chinese has a different approach when it comes to their education. I just dont understand why there is such revolution in it.

[Jason]

Useful info. thanks for sharing.

[live cricket streaming]

Hi. I actually enjoyed reading your writing!. Quality information. I would recommend one to submit articles a bit more frequently. By doing this, having such type of a good site I do think you could potentially rank better inside the search engines like google
Fabulous article. Thank you a lot! live cricket streaming

[Personal Trainer Certification]

Having read this I thought it was very informative. I appreciate you taking the time and effort to put this article together. I once again find myself spending way to much time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was still worth it!

[earache remedies]

Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very useful. Thanks for sharing.

[homemade pancakes]

Your style is so unique compared to many other people. Thank you for publishing when you have the opportunity,Guess I will just make this bookmarked.2

[free iphone apps]

Great line up. We will be linking to this great article on our site. Keep up the good writing.

[business modeling]

This is a very good tips especially to those new to blogosphere, brief and accurate information… Thanks for sharing this one. A must read article.

[live cricket streaming]

Way cool, some valid points! I appreciate you making this article available, the rest of the site is also high quality. Have a fun.

[Mena]

This is a very interesting article...great content. i'm really impressed by your thoughts thanks for sharing your experience.

[Earache Remedies]

Very enlightening post. Even though a bit older - still applies totally.

[xl pharmacy]

I wonder if you have more information about these Chinese tattoos!

[xl pharmacy]

I don't know enough about it but I've heard that Chinese education is so good and that's perfect because I'm thinking on moving to China and I need that that the education there being so good.